Image to Infinity: Rethinking Description and Detail in the Cinema

Patterson, Alison L. (2011) Image to Infinity: Rethinking Description and Detail in the Cinema. Doctoral Dissertation, University of Pittsburgh.

Preview

PDF - Primary Text Download (5Mb) | Preview

Abstract

In the late 1980s, historian Hayden White suggested the possibility of forms of historical thought unique to filmed history. White proposed the study of "historiophoty," an imagistic alternative to written history. Subsequently, much scholarly attention has been paid to the category of History Film. Yet popular concerns for historical re-presentation and heritage have not fully addressed aesthetic effects of prior history films and emergent imagistic-historiographic practices. This dissertation identifies and elaborates one such alternative historiographic practice on film, via inter-medial study attending to British and American history films, an instance of multi-platform digital historiography, and an animated film - a category of film often overlooked in history film studies. Central to this dissertation is Gilles Deleuze's development of varieties of the Movement Image. Deleuze's Movement Image includes the "discursive image," a form which has not yet broken the coherence of sensori-motor connections between the object perceived and the affective response of the viewer. Related to the "discursive image," I propose that the "descriptive image" can capture what the larger category "representation" and the cinema-specific "spectacle" cannot. Drawing from literary and art-historical conceptions of the differences between "descriptive" and "narrative" forms, I propose that in the history film, the "descriptive image" functions as a meta-critical aesthetic, insisting that viewers perceive naturalized relationships as instead contingent. I argue that, rather than a "mature form" of realism, the "descriptive image" is a form of critical realism. Descriptive images are characterized by: long takes of long shots; the co-presence and co-equivalence of objects; a point of view neither neutral nor attributable to a character; and expressions of scope or forms for framing that assert that the given view is only one view from the set of possible views. Thus I examine exemplary texts that demonstrate a difference between "narrative understanding" and "descriptive understanding." These texts, despite their material differences, similarly present mixed historiographic forms, and enable us to see what studies of history on film, in their interest in re-presentation over presentation, have often missed: "descriptive images" allow us to differentiate the event of the film from an inadequate copy of an historical event.

Details
Item Type:	University of Pittsburgh ETD
Creators/Authors:	Creators Email ORCID Patterson, Alison L. alisonpatterson@gmail.com
ETD Committee:	ETD Committee Role Committee Member Email Committee Chair Landy, Marcia mlandy@pitt.edu Committee Member Lowenstein, Adam alowen@pitt.edu Committee Member MacCabe, Colin maccabe@pitt.edu Committee Member Halle, Randall rhalle@pitt.edu Committee Member Boone, Troy boone@pitt.edu
Title:	Image to Infinity: Rethinking Description and Detail in the Cinema
Status:	Unpublished
Abstract:	In the late 1980s, historian Hayden White suggested the possibility of forms of historical thought unique to filmed history. White proposed the study of "historiophoty," an imagistic alternative to written history. Subsequently, much scholarly attention has been paid to the category of History Film. Yet popular concerns for historical re-presentation and heritage have not fully addressed aesthetic effects of prior history films and emergent imagistic-historiographic practices. This dissertation identifies and elaborates one such alternative historiographic practice on film, via inter-medial study attending to British and American history films, an instance of multi-platform digital historiography, and an animated film - a category of film often overlooked in history film studies. Central to this dissertation is Gilles Deleuze's development of varieties of the Movement Image. Deleuze's Movement Image includes the "discursive image," a form which has not yet broken the coherence of sensori-motor connections between the object perceived and the affective response of the viewer. Related to the "discursive image," I propose that the "descriptive image" can capture what the larger category "representation" and the cinema-specific "spectacle" cannot. Drawing from literary and art-historical conceptions of the differences between "descriptive" and "narrative" forms, I propose that in the history film, the "descriptive image" functions as a meta-critical aesthetic, insisting that viewers perceive naturalized relationships as instead contingent. I argue that, rather than a "mature form" of realism, the "descriptive image" is a form of critical realism. Descriptive images are characterized by: long takes of long shots; the co-presence and co-equivalence of objects; a point of view neither neutral nor attributable to a character; and expressions of scope or forms for framing that assert that the given view is only one view from the set of possible views. Thus I examine exemplary texts that demonstrate a difference between "narrative understanding" and "descriptive understanding." These texts, despite their material differences, similarly present mixed historiographic forms, and enable us to see what studies of history on film, in their interest in re-presentation over presentation, have often missed: "descriptive images" allow us to differentiate the event of the film from an inadequate copy of an historical event.
Date:	30 June 2011
Date Type:	Completion
Defense Date:	23 February 2011
Approval Date:	30 June 2011
Submission Date:	14 April 2011
Access Restriction:	No restriction; The work is available for access worldwide immediately.
Patent pending:	No
Institution:	University of Pittsburgh
Thesis Type:	Doctoral Dissertation
Refereed:	Yes
Degree:	PhD - Doctor of Philosophy
URN:	etd-04142011-072549
Uncontrolled Keywords:	Barry Lyndon; Costume Drama; Illustrated History; Kubrick; Landscape Film; Lawrence of Arabia; McCay; Passage to India; Sinking of the Lusitania; Visual Description; Baroque; Deleuze; Greenaway; History Film; Lean; Ryan's Daughter; Movement Image
Schools and Programs:	Dietrich School of Arts and Sciences > English
Date Deposited:	10 Nov 2011 14:37
Last Modified:	04 May 2012 15:47
Other ID:	http://etd.library.pitt.edu/ETD/available/etd-04142011-072549/, etd-04142011-072549

Actions (login required)