Link to the University of Pittsburgh Homepage
Link to the University Library System Homepage Link to the Contact Us Form

From a Genetic Predisposition to an Interactive Predisposition: Rethinking the Ethical Implications of Research on Gene-Environment Interactions

Tabery, James Gregory (2008) From a Genetic Predisposition to an Interactive Predisposition: Rethinking the Ethical Implications of Research on Gene-Environment Interactions. Master's Thesis, University of Pittsburgh. (Unpublished)

[img]
Preview
PDF
Primary Text

Download (550kB) | Preview

Abstract

The concept of gene-environment interaction, or G×E, refers to cases where different genetic groups respond differently to the same array of environments for a particular phenotypic trait. In a widely acclaimed study from 2002, researchers found a case of G×E for a gene associated with neuroenzymatic activity (low vs. high), exposure to childhood maltreatment, and the development of antisocial personality disorder (ASPD), or sociopathy. Cases of G×E are generally characterized as evincing a genetic predisposition to the trait under consideration; for example, individuals with low neuroenzymatic activity are generally characterized as having a genetic predisposition to ASPD. Bioethical commentators in turn have asked: Should parents test their embryos or fetuses for this genetic predisposition to ASPD in order to screen against the gene associated with low-MAOA activity? Should the state test all newborns for this genetic predisposition to ASPD in order to identify and treat individuals with the gene associated with low-MAOA activity from birth? I first show that the concept of a genetic predisposition fundamentally misconstrues the ASPD study. That concept is appropriately applied only to cases of G×E that result in a change of scale, but the ASPD study resulted in a change of rank. For cases of G×E that result in a change of rank, I introduce a new concept—interactive predisposition. Then, I show how this switch from a genetic predisposition to an interactive predisposition reconfigures old questions and raises new questions in the confines of the ethical discussions about the implications of such studies. For the ASPD study, attempts to screen against the gene associated with low-MAOA activity potentially fall prey to the myth of pre-environmental prediction, and attempts to screen all newborns for the gene associated with low-MAOA activity with an eye towards early intervention will have to face the interventionist's dilemma. Moving beyond the ASPD study, traditional cost-benefit analyses involved in deciding whether or not to undertake the genetic testing of a child will have to be reweighed when the disease/disorder of concern results from an interactive predisposition rather than a genetic predisposition.


Share

Citation/Export:
Social Networking:
Share |

Details

Item Type: University of Pittsburgh ETD
Status: Unpublished
Creators/Authors:
CreatorsEmailPitt UsernameORCID
Tabery, James Gregorytabery@philosophy.utah.edu
ETD Committee:
TitleMemberEmail AddressPitt UsernameORCID
Committee ChairParker, Lisalisap@pitt.eduLISAP
Committee MemberParens, Erikparense@thehastingscenter.org
Committee MemberSchaffner, Kennethkfs@pitt.eduKFS
Committee MemberWicclair, Markwicclair@pitt.eduWICCLAIR
Date: 16 January 2008
Date Type: Completion
Defense Date: 12 October 2007
Approval Date: 16 January 2008
Submission Date: 14 October 2007
Access Restriction: No restriction; Release the ETD for access worldwide immediately.
Institution: University of Pittsburgh
Schools and Programs: Dietrich School of Arts and Sciences > Bioethics
Degree: MA - Master of Arts
Thesis Type: Master's Thesis
Refereed: Yes
Uncontrolled Keywords: Behavioral Genetics; Bioethics; Children; Ethics; Gene-Environment Interaction; Genetic Predisposition; Genetic Screening; Genetic Testing; Interactive Predispositions; Nature-Nurture Debate; Newborn Screening; Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis
Other ID: http://etd.library.pitt.edu/ETD/available/etd-10142007-213310/, etd-10142007-213310
Date Deposited: 10 Nov 2011 20:03
Last Modified: 15 Nov 2016 13:50
URI: http://d-scholarship.pitt.edu/id/eprint/9465

Metrics

Monthly Views for the past 3 years

Plum Analytics


Actions (login required)

View Item View Item